You are here: Home » Specials » Weekend
Business Standard

Does a fat tax help?

While burgers and pizzas have been taxed, fattening Indian foods like samosa and jalebis have been left out

Veenu Sandhu 

Kerala's Communist Party of India (Marxist)-led Left Democratic Front government has taken the fight against fat to the next level. It has announced a 14.5 per cent "fat tax" on burgers, pizzas, donuts, tacos, sandwiches and pasta served in branded restaurants and fast food chains like McDonald's, Burger King and Pizza Hut. The move has invited sharp reactions from outlets selling these food items. It has also triggered a debate on whether or not a fat tax acts as a deterrent and prevents people from eating unhealthy, fattening junk food. Not everybody agrees that it does. Shikha Sharma, the founder of Delhi-based Nutri-Health, feels that the Kerala government has made too many assumptions in understanding obesity. "First, it has assumed that a tax will act as a deterrent. And second, it has assumed that taxing only certain food items will be enough to help bring down obesity," she says. While burgers, pizzas and so on have been taxed, Indian food items like samosa, jalebi, poori and kachori, which are also fattening, have been left out. "Do they really think that only fast-food served by multinational chains causes obesity?" Sharma asks. Experts feel that the idea has not been scientifically thought out. For example, when Denmark introduced the world's first ever fat tax in 2011, it taxed all foods with a saturated fat content of above 2.3 per cent, including cheese, butter, oil, milk and meat. It's another story that the country scrapped the tax in 2013 because it failed to solve the problem of obesity. The Kerala government has also left beverages high in sugar content out of the tax purview, unlike Hungary that had taxed foods high in sugar, salt and fat like soft drinks, chocolate bars and chips. Mexico too taxes sugary drinks, breakfast cereals and sweets and calls it the "sin tax".

Similarly, France has a "sin tax" on carbonated drinks like colas. Kerala does need a plan to fight obesity considering that, according to the National Family Health Survey, the state has the second-highest rate of childhood obesity in the country. Adults in the state also do not fare any better. Kerala's fat tax targets the middle income group and the rich, but not the common man. So, a 14.5 per cent tax would mean that a Rs 100 burger would cost Rs 114.5. That, say experts, isn't steep enough to make someone from that social status to forego a burger. A study conducted on the fat tax in Mexico showed that while there was marked reduction in the consumption levels of low and medium socio-economic status households after the tax was imposed, it did not change the consumption patterns in high socio-economic status households. Pradeep Chowbey, chairman, Max Institute of Minimal Access, Metabolic and Bariatric Surgery, Saket, New Delhi, is, however, optimistic. "Agreed, this will in no way impact the sale of these food items. Not even one burger will sell less because of this tax," he says. "But when parents know that this particular food item is branded 'fat', they will discourage their children from having it." Chowbey calls it the very first baby step towards curbing obesity. "This creates a situation where people will think that the food item they are consuming has something which is fattening." He would like to have the words "fat tax" printed in capital letters and in bold on the bill. If this is constantly hammered into the mind, it will, in the long run, make a difference, he says. The state hopes to earn Rs 10 crore a year from the tax. "That is not a lot of money," says Chowbey, "so the intention is clearly to reinforce the thought that what you are consuming is unhealthy." Tobacco activists, who have for years been asking for higher tax on tobacco products, say such schemes work only when even the cheapest product in the category is taxed - such as the bidi, which most state governments do not tax heavily or do not tax at all. Clearly, the Kerala government has just found a soft target to tax, says Sharma. The fight against obesity, she adds, can be fought better if healthier food options are made easily accessible to people - on street sides, near schools and also at fancy eating places.

MONTHLY STAR

Business Standard Digital

Business Standard Digital Monthly Subscription
149.00  
subscribe
Complete access to the premium product
Convenient – Pay as you go
Pay using Master/Visa Credit Card & ICICI VISA Debit Card
Auto renewed (subject to your card issuer’s permission)
Cancel any time in the future
Requires personal information

What you get?

ON BUSINESS STANDARD DIGITAL

  • Unlimited access to all the content on any device through browser or app.
  • Exclusive content, features, opinions and comment – hand-picked by our editors, just for you.
  • Pick 5 of your favourite companies. Get a daily email with all the news updates on them.
  • Track the industry of your choice with a daily newsletter specific to that industry.
  • Stay on top of your investments. Track stock prices in your portfolio.
  • 18 years of archival data.

NOTE :

  • The product is a monthly auto renewal product.
  • Cancellation Policy: You can cancel any time in the future without assigning any reasons, but 48 hours prior to your card being charged for renewal. We do not offer any refunds.
  • To cancel, communicate from your registered email id and send the email with the cancellation request to assist@bsmail.in. Include your contact number for speedy action. Requests mailed to any other ID will not be acknowledged or actioned upon.

SMART MONTHLY

Business Standard Digital

Business Standard Digital - 12 Months
1499.00
subscribe
Get 12 months of Business Standard digital access
Single Seamless Sign-up to Business Standard Digital
Convenient - Once a year payment
Pay using an instrument of your choice - Credit/Debit Cards, Net Banking, Payment Wallets accepted
Exclusive Invite to select Business Standard events

What you get

ON BUSINESS STANDARD DIGITAL

  • Unlimited access to all content on any device through browser or app.
  • Exclusive content, features, opinions and comment – hand-picked by our editors, just for you.
  • Pick 5 of your favourite companies. Get a daily email with all the news updates on them.
  • Track the industry of your choice with a daily newsletter specific to that industry.
  • Stay on top of your investments. Track stock prices in your portfolio.

NOTE :

  • This product is a monthly auto renewal product.
  • Cancellation Policy: You can cancel any time in the future without assigning any reasons, but 48 hours prior to your card being charged for renewal. We do not offer any refunds.
  • To cancel, communicate from your registered email id and send the mail with the request to assist@bsmail.in. Include your contact number for easy reference. Requests mailed to any other ID will not be acknowledged or actioned upon.
First Published: Sat, July 16 2016. 00:15 IST
RECOMMENDED FOR YOU